
The cabinet for the president-elect Mohamed Nasheed was announced this afternoon. Following are some of the observations regarding the proposed cabinet. This isn’t the best Cabinet but 11 of the 14 appointments should be given some time to prove their critics wrong while the other three posts should be reviewed by the Parliament and the new government!
1. Whereas Gayyoom’s Cabinet had more than 20 ministries, Nasheed is proposing only 14. This is a positive change which will reduce bureaucracy and reduce government expenditure as well. Hence this change should be welcomed.
2. As far as the allocation of posts to various parties in the coalition is concerned, it is noted that MDP got five posts, and Gasim’s Jumhooree Gulhun got four posts while Dr. Hassan Saeed’s New Maldives Movement got two posts and Dr. Waheed’s Gaumee Iththihaadh got two posts. Finally Ibra’s Liberal party got one post. Considering the fact that Dr. Hassan Saeed got more votes in the first round than the whole of the Jumhooree Gulhun, it seems unfair that his movement got two seats while Gasim’s party got four seats. It could also be argued that Dr. Waheed’s Gaumee Iththihaadh in effect got three seats because Dr. Waheed himself will sit in the Cabinet – as Vice President.
3. To address this imbalance I would humbly suggest that Dr. Hassan Saeed be made a Special Advisor to the President.
4. Overall it’s not the most competent Cabinet that could be selected from the current crop of young and qualified Maldivians. A much better cabinet could have been selected. This selection smells of political string-pulling! Not every minister has to be educated and qualified in the field of his ministry but at least every minister has to be familiar with his portfolio. In this respect, to put it mildly, the appointment of Dr. Ibrahim Didi isn’t the most intelligent appointment as Fisheries Minister. The same could be said about Jameel’s appointment as Civil Aviations Minister. Dr. Didi is a dentist by profession, and one wonders how Dentist-Didi could address the serious demands in the Fisheries industry. A friend of mine jokingly suggested that Dr. Didi could perhaps setup a good dental service for the arcnut-chewing Maldivian fishermen. For grounds of incompetency I believe that the Parliament would veto this appointment.
5. The same could be said about Ahmed Ali Sawad. A graduate in Sharia and Law, one wonders how Sawad could be a good Tourism Minister. He was also the running mate for Gasim Ibrahim when Gasim ran for president in the first round of the election. Gasim is one of the biggest resort operators in the country and many say that Sawad could be Gasim’s proxy in the Tourism Ministry. This wouldn’t be good news for other major resort operators such as Champa, Universal, Sun land, etc. They may not want their direct competitor to be their boss at the Tourism Ministry! For both these reasons I would think that the Parliament would find enough conflict of interest to veto this appointment.
6. I do not believe that Dr. Musthafa Luthfee would be up to the task of managing the Education Ministry. Though he has a doctorate in the field of education, Dr. Musthafa is a slow and very bureaucratic person.
7. The appointment of Dhiyana Saeed as the Attorney General also is a bad choice given the fact that there are some high-profile issues pending at the Attorney General’s Office regarding her husband Abdullah Jabir. One such issue is the case of Vilivaru and Biyaadhoo resort. This leaves a lot of conflict of interest in this appointment. I would think that the Parliament would find enough conflict of interest to veto this appointment.
8. As I said before, it’s not the most competent Cabinet that could be selected from the current crop of young and qualified Maldivians. A much better cabinet could have been selected. I have reservations about some other appointments too but overall those appointments should be given time to prove their critics wrong. But I would suggest that the Parliament should veto the appointment of Dentist-Didi as Fisheries Minster and the appointment of Sawad as the Tourism Minister and the appointment of Dhiyana Saeed as the Attorney General. These there posts should be reviewed both by the Parliament and the new government! This isn’t the best Cabinet but 11 of the 14 appointments should be given some time to prove their critics wrong while the other three posts should be reviewed by the Parliament and the new government!